Brittney wearing blazer rented from Rent the Runway, sunglasses rented from Rent the Runway, jeans, and boots walking down sidewalk

Nuuly vs Rent the Runway: Which Clothing Rental is Better

Clothing rental services have become more trendy in recent years with Nuuly and Rent the Runway being the two most popular. While outside looking in they can seem like the same service, there are some similarities and key differences in the debate between Nuuly vs Rent the Runway. Having had personal experience using both services, I feel I have a great understanding for which service is best depending on your needs and lifestyle.

As a Floridian, one of my favorite uses of clothing rental services is renting cold weather gear when traveling somewhere cold during the winter. Aside from renting specifically for the changing seasons, rentals can be great for special occasions, vacations, or workwear. I frequently rent clothes to spruce up my wardrobe for upcoming trips to avoid overspending on new clothes.

Why Should You Rent Clothes?

Overall renting clothes can be a more sustainable and affordable option over purchasing the same number of new fast fashion items. Renting clothes also decreases the demand for new clothes. Additionally, clothing rentals can be a great option when needing an item that may only be worn once, like a formal wedding guest dress.

Nuuly vs Rent the Runway: Major Differences

While Nuuly and Rent the Runway both offer rental clothes, there are some obvious differences to consider prior to renting.

Nuuly offers a 6 item monthly rental, while Rent the Runway’s equivalent allows 10 items per month, which includes 2 shipments of 5 items.

Quite noticeably, one major difference is how the items arrive to your doorstep. While both do ship their items in a reusable tote, Rent the Runway ships all items on a hanger and each has its own plastic garment bag. Nuuly, however, simply folds the clothes neatly into their tote. Personally, I’m not a fan of the plastic garment bags, but I do enjoy having the hangers.

In addition, Rent the Runway has the option to rent a single item for 4-8 days, which is great for those seeking something to wear for a special occasion like a wedding or other life event. If you are renting a single item, Rent the Runway also offers a free backup size.

Another key difference, if you’re renting month-to-month, Rent the Runway allows you to keep items and only trade in what you want. While Nuuly requires you to ship all items back. However, Nuuly will allow you to unlock your next month early and Rent the Runway only allows the two shipments and a new month does not begin until your next billing date.

Lastly, Rent the Runway also provides the option to rent handbags and accessories which can help enhance your look, especially if you’re renting for a special occasion.

Nuuly vs Rent the Runway: Similarities

While there are many key differences in the Nuuly vs Rent the Runway debate, there are some similarities, as well.

Though it may seem simple, both platforms allow you to create a favorites list. This can easily help you determine if any item you love is available in your size when it’s time for you to select your items. Users are also able to create multiple lists allowing you to organize items be season or event.

Both rental service also allow you to buy your items at a discounted price. The discount may vary on how new or used he item is, but items are typically at least 10% off.

Of course, both services also allow you to pause or cancel at any time in the event you are only renting on an as needed basis.

Brittney Naylor in long floral maxi dress walking down the stairs at The Don CeSar in Saint Pete. Most Instagrammable Hotel. The Pink Palace
rent the runway
a woman and child walking on a sidewalk, downtown Fernandina Beach, weekend in Fernandina Beach
pants rented from nuuly

Nuuly vs Rent the Runway: Which Service is Best for You?

While both services share some of the same brands, like Farm Rio, Lilly Pulitzer, and a few others, Rent the Runway does have more high end designers and workwear like Tory Burch, Badgley Mischka, and others. I feel that Rent the Runway is the best option for those in the corporate world or looking for high fashion for special events and parties.

On the other hand, Nuuly carries more everyday brands like Anthropologie, Free People, and more, making it the best option for those looking to spruce up their everyday closet or prepping for a vacation.

As someone who chronically buys new clothes for vacation, Nuuly has been my go-to for adding new items to my vacation wardrobe. Which has been great for my wallet.

Brittney and daughter walking through downtown Helen, Georgia. Brittney is wearing a long pea coat rented from Rent the Runway
coat from rent the runway

So, Nuuly or Rent the Runway?

So, there you have it! Nuuly and Rent the Runway both offer a stylish solution to overflowing closets and impulse purchases, but they cater to different fashionistas.

Rent the Runway is your best bet if you crave luxury labels, need a show-stopping outfit for a special occasion, or to navigate the corporate world in style. They have a wider selection of high-end designers and workwear options, plus the perk of keeping items longer if you fall in love.

Nuuly shines for those who want to refresh their everyday wardrobe with on-trend pieces from familiar brands, or who, like me, are chronic vacation outfit accumulators. Nuuly’s focus on casual styles and the ability to unlock your next month’s picks early makes it a perfect choice for refreshing your look without breaking the bank.

Ultimately, the best service depends on your personal style and needs. But hey, with both Nuuly and Rent the Runway offering pause and cancel options, why not give each a try and see which one stitches itself into your fashion routine?

Save Nuuly vs Rent the Runway to Pinterest!

*This post contains affiliate links meaning at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.*

Leave a Comment

The Comments

  • Beth
    June 17, 2024

    These both sound like great services, but I do enjoy that Rent The Runway has a broader collection of high-end designs.

  • Colleen
    June 17, 2024

    These seem like they’re both excellent services. It sounds like it really depends on a person’s needs and wants.

  • barbie ritzman
    June 17, 2024

    Fun. I love that both services also allow you to pause or cancel at any time if you are renting on an as-needed basis. This comparison is so helpful

  • Ramil Hinolan
    June 18, 2024

    The financial advantage of renting clothes rather than buying brand new ones is fantastic. It’s a smart and stylish way to keep your wardrobe fresh without breaking the bank.

  • Stephanie
    June 18, 2024

    I didn’t know renting clothing was a thing! This is so clever and such an affordable way to up my fashion sense. Thanks for the honest review of both companies – ‘Rent the Runway’ sounds good to me as I could use a little luxury.

  • pedja
    June 18, 2024

    These services both sound excellent and flexible, offering the ability to pause or cancel anytime. Thanks for sharing!

  • Richard Lowe
    June 18, 2024

    Both options look like they offer great clothes. I like your photos and the styles you chose.

  • LisaLisa
    June 18, 2024

    Wow this is interesting! Never thought about renting clothing before I like the selection’s ideas you selected from both companies.

  • Michelle
    June 18, 2024

    I’ve never thought to rent clothes, but this is such a brilliant idea! I would love to use one of these services to spruce up my wardrobe for my next vacation.

  • Melanie williams
    June 18, 2024

    You look amazing and these sound like really super duper services. I love the pretty dress and such summer vibes xx

  • Marysa
    June 18, 2024

    Ohhh, what a great comparison of the two! I haven’t tried either, and this was very interesting to read. I would love to try a service like this.

  • Clarice
    June 19, 2024

    I had no idea that clothes rental is such a thing. I mean that’s not really common here in our place aside from wedding gowns and formal wear but based on the two choices, renting from Nuuly would be more appropriate for me since I tend to buy new clothes for vacation.

  • Fransic verso
    June 19, 2024

    I don’t think I’ve seen any of my friends doing this rental clothing service but it’s interesting and this post has good things to consider.

  • Archana Singh
    June 20, 2024

    I have never rented clothes, but I have been hearing about this trend for a long time. And, I would love to try it on my next trip. I am into sustainable living and renting clothes will be perfect for me. Thanks for the inspiration.